As is well recorded , the derby has been the nemesis of many fancied runners over the years. The last couple of years have been relatively better off as the Favorite has WON. The past decade or so the race has had its share of firm favorites , some won many lost . This year looks different due to the multiple contenders and no clear market favorite is visible . This is on account of lack of consistent performances of the leading contenders but for In the Spot Light which has been in tremendous winning form. However all its Wins have at other centres and the horse is making its debut at the Mahalakshmi tracks which may or may not be to its advantage.
Be that as it may , how much ever we try to analyse the chances of the various competing horses , it is practically difficult to give a clear Winner for various reasons. Yes , at the end of the day , there would be a Winner and if 8 Analysts opt for a different horse , one of them shall take the honors. That rarely happens as people tend to concentrate on the select few horses in the fray and come to conclusions which may or may not be prejudiced . This is my attempt to try to solve the complex puzzle .
Going by the ratings and the bloodlines , not many would give a chance to Astapi , Pronto Star , Maruader , Knighton and Ranthambore. Out of the rest , 4 are rated above 100 on account of its impressive record in classic . 3 horses are rated above 90 and surprisingly the only horse rated below 90 is the highly regarded Hills and Stars.
Starting from the top -
In the Spotlight - the multi classic Winner has done nothing wrong since the derby Win @ Malakpet. It has maintained its unbeaten streak since then with 3 Victories in the Kolkata Classics, where the competition was frankly not upto the mark. The manner in which it Won its races was very very impressive . The margin of victory was too good to be true , the timings clocked no mean feat. Its well bred , has got tuned to the jockey , is bred to stay and has amazing turn of foot. It did lose twice to Southern Bay at Mysore and one can put it to the relatively poor saddle support. Unlike the other race tracks the Mumbai straight is very strenuous and the tactics used at Kolkata cant be used. Having seen different tracks , i guess the Winning horses will easily adapt itself to the mumbai course. A good chance.
Smashing And Cardinal are both trained by P.Shroff and despite Winning a couple of races this season , its going to be a tough task to handle the derby field. Cardinal has limitations on staying the trip and the last effort was laboured. Smashing did Win the Oaks , the timings clocked and the short time to recover may hamper its progress. Oaks Winners have gone on to win the derby when the field was not competitive , not going to be easy here.
Pronto Pronto the multi classic Winner seems to be have the TAG of the underdog always. All his Wins have been accomplished when experts raised doubts on its capabilities. Has showed good fighting capability by coming from impossible positions to Win in earlier outings. Has had a feel of the local tracks while annexing the 2000 Guineas. The subsequent mock race has ensured that it is fit. Can it do the distance ?? One can only think positively and hope for the best. The sire is not known for its classic Wins over derby distance , the solitary Win coming through Diabolical , a pillar to post winner , when the field was relatively poor but for the favorite . Rider Y.S.Srinath is not in the best of form but seems to relish winning for the Owners in the big races be it on Pronto Pronto , Oasis Star or Riyasat . The temper mental jockey will decide its fate as a over confident ride will ruin its chances. Has never Won the Indian Derby since making his debut as a Jockey and that surely will have to be factored. Cant rule out its chances.
Star Marquess , the Got abroad , has been the under performer , having Won just once since making debut. Is bred to stay but a difficult horse to handle .Lacked finishing skills at bangalore. Has run close to Pronto Pronto and Cardinal both of whom are competing here.The effort in the RRR gold cup was praise worthy , looks like it relishes the long mumbai straight which may enable a improved performance. On current form a chance for place.
Field Marshall , is a Derby Winner , albeit at Mysore , has beaten Southern Bay , that by itself is an achievement. Is known to hit the front from the word go and not many give it a chance here . It can stay the trip without any doubts , the presence of stable mate in the fray may give the impression that it would be a mere pace setter. At times trainer's use the lead up races to mislead the competitors into a false sense of security. Tactics can change on D day. Front runners have the advantage always if they can cut a decent clip as was evident in Noble Eagle and Diabolical Wins. There is no need to take a long lead and lose the plot. Giving rests at various stages of the race without extending the horse and reserving the best for the final 600 metres can upset all calculations. Usually the jockeys in the back end do go under the assumption that the front runner will tire down and crossing him is a formality. Sadly many upsets have taken place due to lack of judgement . Owner is yet to Win the Derby having failed narrowly with Holding Court. Jockey merit will decide its fate. Cant rule out a upset.
Picasso - the PBM Winner , 3 rd entry from Shroff. bred to STAY . The pune derby debacle is best forgotten. Not many fancied it when it was entrusted to a mediocre rider like C.Alford. The form displayed in 2011 was awesome. Has not Won a race for a pretty long time. The jockey is one of the best and the Owners past masters in Winning classic when least fancied. Does come with a flourish in the closing stages and that is an advantage if positioned well. The Sire is yet to taste Derby Success , the Dam is good enough to give One here.
Leaving us with Hills and Stars , the winner of the Pune Derby , beating Cardinal and Maruader. The only run in Mumbai this season was quite poor. Horse was not fit , the jockey did not do justice by getting boxed at an important stage of the race. The Trainer is hospitalised and NONE aware as to who is manging the show. No transparency at all. With the Poonawala family picking up a stake and the presence of R Hughes in the saddle there is bound to be confidence in its ability to do well.Bred to stay , not many Pune derby Winners have done well subsequently, That cant be used against this filly. The jockey prefers to ride along the rails and has been fortunate to Win many races this way, despite traffic problems. Noone here will give him a free run and unless he decides to change the strategy its not easy. Is the lowest rated horse among the fancied runners.
The 3 fillies in the fray are better off in the scales by 1.50 kgs but that may not matter as Colts have the ability to overcome this by virtue of their staying capability.
| Astapi | 61 | 50 | 10 |
| Picasso | 92 | 15 | 4 |
| Cardinal | 102 | 12 | 2.5 |
| Pronto Pronto | 100 | 6 | 1.5 |
| Field Marshall | 96 | 20 | 5 |
| Pronto Star | 43 | 100 | 50 |
| Knighton | 47 | 100 | 50 |
| Ranthambore | 82 | 100 | 25 |
| Maruader | 63 | 100 | 50 |
| Star Marquess | 97 | 10 | 2 |
| Hills and Stars | 84 | 5 | 1.5 |
| In the Spot Light | 110 | 3 | 0.75 |
| Smashing | 105 | 6 | 1.5 |