March 8, 2015

Diabolical Minds - What goes around, comes around



"as you sow, so shall you reap"

Remarkable coincidences

Year 2007  McDOWELL INDIAN DERBY (2,400m), 4-y-o only:

1.DIABOLICAL (MAJOR IMPACT-DOUBLE QUICK) 57 O'DONOGHUE 1,
2.SOUTHERN EMPIRE (Placerville-Stunning) 57 B. Prakash 2
3.BLUE RIBBON (Alnasr Alwasheek-Endorsement) 55.5 McCullagh 3 
4. LOMBARDIA (Razeen-Naseem El Fajr) 55.5 Kharadi 4.

All ran. 2-1/2, 4-1/4 and 6-1/4. 2m 30.27s.

Winner - Diabolical - Owned by MAM , ridden by Colm O Donoghue , Odds 25 to 1.  Horse had just about returned after Winning Hyd Derby a week prior , hence not many experts or punters gave it a chance to Win.

Favorite was stable Mate , Southern Empire @ Odds 30/100 ridden by Stable retainer B Prakash. Experts stated It was a walkover as there were only few horses in the fray. Guess only presentation ceremony was pending  but alas ...

One month later -  Indian Turf Invitation Cup 2,400m: 

Southern Empire (’Donoghue) 1
Diabolical (Rajendra) 2;
Silver Print (Mallesh) 3;
Super Speed (Suraj) 4.  

Won by: Dist; Dist; Dist; (2-28.09)

So racegoers were told  that A Horse can reverse verdict by 15 lenghts in a span of 1 month.


Year 2015 McDOWELL SIGNATURE INDIAN DERBY (Gr.1) (2,400m), 4-y-o only

1.Be Safe (Holy Roman Emperor – Oriental Lady) (Suraj Narredu)
2.Tiger Tops (Tiger Hill – Cockyane) (Colm O’DOnoghue)
3.Quasar (Seeking the Dia – Belle Jour) (Y.S.Srinath)
4.Aquamarine (Mastercraftsman – Pilgrim’s Way) (D.K.Ashish) .

Won by - 4-1/2, Nk, Nk. 2m 27.71s.

One month later -

Omkar Indian Turf Invitation Cup: Distance 2,400m:

1.Quasar (Yash) 
2.Be Safe (Suraj )
3.Amazing Grace ( Trevor )
4.Alaindair ( Srinath )

Won by: Nk, 2-1/4; (2-28.73).

Going by the logic given earlier , 1 horse Improved in a Month , after being well rested.So basically it was a reverse verdict on the ODDS front , same owner involved in both incidents. So why should anyone have sympathy now . Not that this was the only DOOSRA of MAM in his career. This was just One of the several incidents in the year 2007.

Read this review - to understand how dubious owner MAM operated those DAYS

http://www.indiarace.com/FullReview.aspx?ReviewId=635

it was back in October last year when racegoers were let down by B. Prakash ridden Ruben Star in the Pune Derby. But neither his owner Dr M. A. M. Ramaswamy nor trainer S.Ganapathy sulked because the horse to pull the plug on the favourite was wearing the same colours as the loser only the cap was different. The winner was Secret Memory and
C. Rajendra was in the saddle. The following month Real Excellence with Prakash in the seat was, asusual, the favourite to win the Bangalore 1000 Guineas but was shocked
by the stable's second hope Star Luminary, who was steered by Irishman Colm O'Donoghue.

Ramaswamy and Ganapathy once again rejoiced. The horse that had donethe trick was their own albeit in the second colours. Cut to Mahalaxmi where one saw Haunting Memories ridden by Prakash being upstaged by stablemate Guest Connections in the Indian 1000 Guineas. The man in action on the winner was none other than Rajendra. This time too the owner-trainer duo did not lose any sleep.

So what if the favourite had not won, the record books would still showthat the Indian classic was won by them.On Republic Day the scene shifted to the Bangalore Derby where SecretMemory with first retainer Prakash to guide his fortunes was thefavourite. Visiting rider O'Donoghue got the responsibility of pilotingStar Luminary. The venue had changed but the script remained the same.Secret Memory failed to connect but Star Luminary kept the racing baron's flag flying high.

There were no surprises as far as Ramaswamy and Ganapathy were concerned. Finally came the turn of the McDowell Indian Derby last Sunday. Southern Empire, who had ruled with an iron hand since his debut, was the rage among the bettors. Some even thought that the bookies werebeing generous by offering 10 to 3 on for the joint property of
Ramaswamy and Zavaray Poonawalla. Despite everything that had happened in the months gone by, racegoers steadfastly believed that Southern Empire was invincible.

If ever there was somebody who had written these scripts, he certainly does not have a heart for Indian horse-racing. For what was being considered as an equine splendour by all and sundry (barring of course those few who thought that Southern Empire is great only because the 2002 crop was inferior) was humiliated in the mother of all battles
fought on the racetrack. Diabolical, racing in the same colours as Southern Empire but ridden by somebody with a destiny different than B. Prakash, humbled the darling of thousands of racegoers in the McDowell Indian Derby. People wanted to know, after the race of course, why Prakash had kept Southern Empire so far behind the front running Diabolical during the course of the race.

There were many other such questions which remained unanswered but it is to the credit of the Manjri Stud bred Diabolical (Major Impact-Double Quick) that he conquered a horse considered to be unbeatable within a week of winning the Hyderabad Derby. The anguish of the racegoers at the loss of Southern Empire can be judged from the fact that Ramaswamy was at the receiving end of their ire when he stepped on to the stage to receive the grand prize. Life nonetheless has finally come a full circle for Prakash as far as his Derby rides are concerned. He has lost yet another Derby when riding Bold Faith in Delhi. Celtic Princess, the eventual winner, incidentally, wore the same colours as Bold Faith.

I am no fan of the Narredu clan but
If B Prakash made an error of judgement in 2007 , why is Suraj Narredu not given the benefit of doubt. If Owner MAM can't instruct C.Donoghue to stop riding & wait for B.Prakash to overtake Diabolical , why should M.Narredu ask his Son to stop riding on Quasar. Punters who lost in all classics in 2007 did not complain as much as is being done now. What has changed. Is it because MAM has aged or Money has become cheaper now ?? In any case i have no sympathy for the Punters who Play at 30/100 or 40 /100 Odds and then complain as if the world has come to an end.

No judgement on the way the race was run in 2015 or 2007. Just  placing facts in Public domain.