October 7, 2008

Contenders for Pune Derby


My personal opinion on the classic ;

Tipsters and racing experts always hold their views based on the certain time tested parameters like : the CLASS of the horse ,the Horses it has competed with and the Horses against whom it WON / Lost to , the timings, the handicap , the choice of the Jockey, the manner of running , the track conditions etc.,

Autonomy :

Based on some of these presumptions Autonomy stands heads and shoulders over the rest.It had beaten Set Alight but was later demoted due to the objection and subsequently it had beaten the highly rated Red Romeo in Mumbai. After a long break ,the horse was given a feel of the pune track when it lost to in a tight finish to Flaming Ace after conceding some weight.But the point to note was that most of the other Horses in the field had done nothing till date , save Juventus and hence this run or performance should be viewed in the right perspective.

It is ONLY one of SIX Horses which has competed with the best in the country and hence the prefered CHOICE of many .There are those who look at the breeding of the horse to analyse and form a view on the potential of the Horses and its capabilities.On this , i always prefer to go by the DAM and not the Sire.Here Autonomy siblings have turned out to be a failure as both Olivia Valere and All Heart cant be classified as Genuine Class Horses.Both were average Horses which did well based on the relative handicap factor.However there should be no concerns on the staying ability over the derby distance as this Horse is bred to stay.Besides the Pune course does not test the ability of the Horse on this Count as even Genuine milers also traverse the trip easily.

Antonios : There is a lot of Hype on its capabilities after its effort in dancing Dynamite race.Though this Horse is bred to stay iam not convinced particularly after its loss to Aurora Aurealis.I do know that the Horse lost its way in the betting and the Jockey was pathetic but when Trainers fool around it is difficult guage the actual potential.No doubt the subsequent run was very good but if the handicap advnatge is factored in, then the performance looks ordinary though the timings for the race reflect a marked improvement.Choice of jockey will definitely indicate intentions as the Owners have PHENOMENALE also in the fray.Due to the limited runners , this Horse could be used as pace setter also.

Phenomenale :

HYPE or class will be known after the race.As it has just WON a single race in CLASS IV beating some mediocre horses , it is difficult to guage its actual potential.It is a stayer par excellence based on pedigree and hence the first run over 1200 in mumbai was a bit of a surprise as it was made to run without much preparation.the choice of the Jockey was also a bit of a letdown.After a very long lapse of time it was tried in Pune over 1600 metres.It won convincingly and also clocked a smart time and manner of winning was good but the others in the field were LOW on quality.

Flaming Ace : Surprise winner last time out beating Autonomy in a tight finish over 1600 mts.But it is very very difficult in the derby as it is running on level terms.Also its capability over the distance is a question mark .Irrespective of the pace of the race or the Jockey declared to ride , this Horse does not have much of a chance.

Rising Hero :Not many would concur with my views but i genuinely feel that this Horse could upset all calculations. A good 2 nd to Dancing Glory over 1400 mts , it was a belated effort ( Kolkatta Derby Winner : Ascriptive ended 4 th ) and then a good 3 rd to Dancing Dynamite does reveal that the Horse has immense potential.Not to forget that Amyn Merchant had ridden this Horse when it finished 3 rd to Dancing Dynamite.( he had ridden DD on debut and regularly rides for M Shah ) the dam is a confirmed stayer and its earlier sibling HOLD the TIGER has always relished longer distances.Tthe two runs in Pune have to be analysed in the true perspective as in the first Run , a notorious and mediocre Jockey going by the name of I Shaikh was declared to ride primarily for the ODDS.The very fact that this Horse was the fancied runner in spite of the Jockey gives credence to its quality.It lost the race due to poor judgement but its subsequent WIN was good enough to merit attention.The manner of running and WINNING indicates that it would do very well over extended distances and it has the class to compete with the best.Whether it does well on the appointed day will depend on the intentions of the concerned individuals and the Jockey declared to ride but to me THIS IS A horse which should not be ignored.



and Finally Dancing Dynamite : Frontline contender after its Four consequent wins. Progeny of Glory of Dancer and Double Wish , the introductory Run was a Shock / surprise to one and all as it was completely ignored ; mainly due to the choice of the Jockey.Subsequent Victory over Ascriptive / Rising Hero in Mumbai and Aquadisiac / Antonions in Pune have established Credentials further.

The Win in a class 2 race in pune was a good effort though one could feel that the others were not fit enough on that day.Then we have the WIN under controvesial circumstances against Antonios..Not many may fancy the chances against AUTONOMY but the if one goes through the pattern of running and its finishing efforts , particularly from the bend position the balance may tilt in its favor.the horse was never extended and hence gives the feeling that it has never been tested.Last run may look bad , but that was becasue the rider did not position it well and was always right behind Antonios which hampered its running.

Based on my reading of the race ; ( assuming that all are running and with some decent JOCKEYS )

Autonomy will start as favorite , odds between 1.00 to 1.20 followed by Dancing Dynamite at odds of 2.00 - 2.50, Antonios may be offered at 6 to 1, Phenomenale at 10 to 1, Flaming Ace at 15 to 1 and Rising Hero the least fancied Horse at odds of 20 to 1.



My choice as of Now is Dancing Dynamite with a small chance for Rising Hero.These could change by race day based on the choice of jockey the track conditions and the ODDS.



Comments and feed back welcome,



SHYAM

1 comment:

  1. Very reasoned analysis, Mr Shyam. I had completely discounted Rising Hero, but after reading your post, this horse needs to be factored in.

    ReplyDelete


Comments are welcome . They are not moderated to allow free speech. If comments are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous , they could be deleted at later stage . Kindly avoid disclosing personal information of individuals . Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of the blog.

Blogging is a form of sharing information & views . I am glad if blog has proved to be of some Value to all visitors. I prefer to reply on matters relating to racing , when addressed by a person with a Name .