The Indian Derby has not been very kind to Favorites . Either the favoritism is misplaced or the luck of the event does not favour these horses. That is one reason why people always keep reiterating it is an open race . It is a grueling trip of 2400 metres , the club has been kind enough to hold it @ 5.30 pm.
How many horses have ever competed during this time of the day. Not that it will affect the performance , just these horses are tuned to run early morning and late afternoon.
We do have a long list of horses participating , the progress of some of these will depend on how well the jockeys position the horses in the early stages of the race.
At times it does seem that over derby trip , its very difficult to cover a lot of ground in the home stretch. Hence a jockey who keeps it in handy position will be able to extract the best in the last 400 metres.
The outer draw does affect performance to some extent but it can be overlooked if horse has exceptional quality.
Without going into the specifics of the Pretenders , I would list them as follows –
Angel Crown , Honest Pleasure , Commander , Maximus , Super Storm , Song Dynasty and Montezuma.
With this we are left to analyse the balance 10 and these are my views. I may have reservations on some of these horses , comments may be negative , but the fact that these are in Contender List does mean they are all capable of doing well.
- An Acquired Taste – was an impressive winner of the RRR gold cup. The horse did not take too kindly and had to take a joint injection on the next day. Though it beat 2 fancied horses , we could see it tiring in the closing stages . In the 2000 G , rider used different tactics , kept it at tail end and made his effort only in the straight , gained a lot of ground in the last furlong. . I would not give it much of a chance to Win.
2.Borsalino – Has Won 2 classics but not in the recent past . Has Beaten as well as Lost to fancied horses participating here. Tactics of going start to finish has not worked as this rider has not been up to the task. The kolkata sojurn was a bad move. May be a bit too late to change tactics of running pillar to post . There are a few pace setters in the fray who can ruin its progress.
3.Caesar’s Star – One of the qualities to look is the staying capability of the horse. In a slow run race all horses will stay the trip . But in a fast run race , the pedigree matters. Those who are not ideally bred to stay will find it difficult to maintain momentum in the last 200 metres which makes a material difference to the outcome of the race. They will finally finish in the rut. C.Star has done this trip , albeit with poor opposition. That does not make it any inferior as most horses in the fray have lost to Inferior horses be it Machiavellianism or Borsalino or Shivalik hero. Jockey S De Souza is well experienced and quite capable of springing a surprise.
4.Hemisphere – a horse which has Won only Once in its career and that too in the hands of I.Pasha . If the same horse was from some other stable , not many would give it a chance to even place. However the names P Shroff and R Hughes will ensure that it is supported to some extent. As far as its chances , it would require a Herculean effort to Win considering its inexperience though it ran well in last 2 outings.
5.Machiavellianism – the contender from Hyderabad who has been in the limelight right from debut. Does very well when punters write it off , falters badly when expected to perform. One off day is acceptable , but 2 losses in last 3 runs ?? is not a positive sign. The fact that it has not Won a race beyond a mile would linger in the minds of the pessimistic race goers . Though P.S.Chouhan has done very well at all centers , lack of Indian derby experience and doubts on staying capability makes me opine chances are bleak .
6. New World – Cleared maiden ranks this season , rated 55 , surely not in this league would be the initial thoughts. The reason for having a second look is its unexpected 4 th in the RRR Gold cup to An Acquired Taste . The horses which finished ahead all fancied here. Hence if not for Win , one can consider it for Place. Relatively inexperienced having Won a class IV race , support is on account of its Pedigree , jockey capability is unknown factor. I would have preferred P.Trevor , who has had a feel of the horse.
7.Shivalik Hero – last won a race in Pune beating Blue Ace and Winston. The horse has finished Thrice in superior company but I could not notice any acceleration at any stage of the race. It was just running the distance and those who had it in them Overtook this horse at various stages of the race. To win a classic , you need to show some aggression which was lacking in last 3 runs. It lost to Commander which is ignored by many experts. So why give this horse so much importance , is it due to Jockey , Trainer , Owner or Pedigree ?? On past performance , I doubt its ability to stay the trip.
8.Snowscape – the proverbial dark horse in the fray. One unexpected Win in Kolkata over derby distance has pitchforked it to prominence. Having been accustomed to winning races at his will , it would be quite a task for C.Alford to Win the feature event of Indian racing. It did stay the trip and won without being extended on friendly tracks. The long mumbai straight will not help matters. Owner has Won this event , jockey sadly has not shown his proves even in regular handicap races on Mumbai tracks. His first run this season and in the feature event.
9. Wind Stream – Has done exceedingly well after shifting leaving the stables of Arjun Manglorkar. The Win in Mysore derby was an eye opener as it finished remarkably well . Maintained its winning form in bangalore while annexing the 2000 guineas on december 8 th. Skipped local derby to have a go at this prestigious event. Has been doing well in tracks , the long gap in between the races have to be considered as a weakness. The horses it beat in 2000 Guineas have been proved beyond doubt to be very inferior. Its mysore win was against Borsalino and Super Storm . Pedigree experts feel it will stay the trip . Based on the expert opinion of all those who matter the Bookies will open it as favorite with Generous Odds. Race Fitness matters a lot and I genuinely feel that long absence does not help matters.I hope it does well , as there are many who love to back favorites and wait for payouts after the race . Why bother about pedigree , distance , jockey capability , track conditions etc.,
10. Winds of Fortune – Whoever has named it deserves a round of applause seeing its progress from class VB to participating in Indian Derby. The late entry adds to the Aura on its chances. 4 long distance races in the past 2 months have taken a toll on the horse , is unanimous opinion. Yet the owner and trainer in their wisdom have paid late fee of Rs 9 lac. Is it to deflect focus from the Favorite or they have seen something that others haven’t will be known after the race. Having seen its last 3 runs and the manner in which it devoured ground and won easily , one must admit , horse has potential to perform, Will it be tired on derby day or can maintain winning form is to be seen. Having regard to the saying “ don’t Ignore Horse in Form “ it is fair to expect a good show in the hands of pocket dynamite Dasrath Singh who rode Commander with Aplomb in Pune derby. Nothing is impossible in racing.
My choices will be posted in the regular thread for Sunday Races.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are welcome . They are not moderated to allow free speech. If comments are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous , they could be deleted at later stage . Kindly avoid disclosing personal information of individuals . Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of the blog.
Blogging is a form of sharing information & views . I am glad if blog has proved to be of some Value to all visitors. I prefer to reply on matters relating to racing , when addressed by a person with a Name .