October 7, 2013

Mint Approach



This concerns the recent run of Mint Approach a horse whose pattern of running is well known to racing public. It has always been seen cutting the pace from the word go . This horse had Won in both starts in Mumbai in an impressive manner.

In debut run race 298 ,  there was  a dead heat for 1 st place with Isodoro the latter could manage to level position at the post. In its 2 nd run over 1400 metres in race 371 , it won beating a high quality field consisting of Alaindair , Archie , Rekindle , Bombardier and Ministerian. On both these occasions it was not the fancied runner and horse weighed around 424 kgs.

Hence when it was scheduled to run the first time in Pune in race # 98 , there was a lot of anticipation as the horse it had beaten earlier in Mumbai had recently annexed Blr Derby .However it was a anticlimax as horse had Put on 31 kilos in the interim period and ran like a dud. The odds drifted very badly and it was a sign of things to come. By the time punters were aware of Weight Increase it was a bit too late and Mission was achieved for Trainer. Horses putting on weight and losing are not common to this trainer as past instances are in public domain. As a horse grows there is a tendency to put on weight but when Horses are Winning only by losing weight and losing when putting weight the signs are visible.

In next outing which was race 150 ,  public fancy was classy Silver Arrow
& Mint Approach cut a fast pace till the bend but could not match strides with superior horse and finished 2 nd  .Based on this run and its previous performances , horse was expected to Win in race 198 against Deep Diver ( which is obviously not in the same league as Alaindair or Silver Arrow )

Yet race time pointers were in favour of Deep Diver and results justified the support. Contrary to its known running style , Mint Approach was ridden in check and was a distance behind Deep Diver right through the first 1000 metres of the race. Jockey made his move only when the result was foregone conclusion. As to why he had ridden in this manner the race day report says –

Trainer Dallas Todywalla and Jockey A.Sandesh were questioned regarding the running and riding of MINT APPROACH. The Trainer stated that his Instructions were to be in 2nd or 3rd position and to ride his race. The Trainer added that he has been training the filly to relax and ride her. He added that the Jockey informed him that the filly relaxed a bit too much after the start as he settled her and took time to get into rhythm. He further stated that the filly could have won the race if the Jockey was able to position the filly as instructed. The Jockey confirmed the Instructions and added that the pace became too fast in the early part. The explanation was noted.

Basic decency demands that Punters ( who are always affected due to inconsistent running ) are informed of any change in pattern . Even assuming that Punters don’t deserve to know change in strategy , isn’t it required to inform Stipes / Stewards of race club prior to the running of the race to avoid Riot like situations. What is the use informing the tactics after the race. How can this be correlated to the facts.

In the end only person who benefited hugely by loss of Mint Approach was the trainer as He was in the know of the result prior hand.  Dallas Todywala is known for controversial racing practices and no wonder the maximum number of failed favorites are from his yard. Horses like War Horse , Colorful Prince , Mint Approach , Emperor of France , La Traviata , Zoravar , Falco Nero , Silver Streak , Dancing Pheonix ,  Ganghor , Brindaban have performed poorly when ODDS drift at race time. Horses are not sighted at the busy end in most cases.

In Kolkata where racing is absolutely atrocious there is some transparency in these matters as borne by these race day reports

5th RACE (67) THE GREAT SCOT HANDICAP – For Horses Rated 41-66, Rated 21-46 eligible (About) 1200 Metres (3.45/3.51) : 9 runners

Prior to the running of the race, Ms. Arti Doctor, the trainer of dk b g WHAT A FEELING,  informed the Stipendiary Stewards that her charge would be ridden in restrain during the early and middle stages of the race.  At the conclusion of the running of the race, the Stipendiary Stewards when enquiring into the poor performance of the gelding, Ms. Arti Doctor stated that in her professional opinion her charge was better suited to race over a longer distance.  The Stipendiary Stewards noted her explanation and advised her to judiciously place her charge when running next.  


Tr. D M David was charged under Rule  159(c) as being a party to the breach of the rule which states every horse shall be run on its merits in that he gave Jockey B Sreekanth instructions that were not compatible with the known style of running of the filly which  in the past had proved  to be  very successful, thereby, he caused his charge to be placed in a position of disadvantage even before the race was run.  Further, he violated the Calendar Notification  appended below  :-

“Trainers are hereby informed that when, by or on behalf of a trainer, any instruction is given to, or arrangement made with the rider of a horse engaged in a race that the horse be ridden in the race in a manner different from the manner in which the horse was ridden at its most recent start or starts, it shall be the responsibility of the trainer or his duly authorised  agent to notify the Stipendiary Stewards of any such instruction or arrangement as early as practicable but not later than when the order to mount is given by the Paddock Officer prior to the race.  Upon receipt of that notification, the Stipendiary Stewards may make any public release in respect thereof as they deem to be appropriate”.

The Stewards continued with the enquiry and after due deliberations, taking into consideration the submissions made by Tr. D M David, the record of the Trainer and mitigating factors  decided to fine Tr. D M David a sum of Rs. 25,000/-  for being a party to the breach of Rules of Racing and for violating the Calendar Notification.  He was also once again cautioned to ensure that his charges are run and ridden in a manner that leaves no room for query.  The Trainer was informed of his right to appeal.

At RWITC , Trainers and jockeys who are associated with Top Owners are rarely questioned or suspended. Often they find some bakras and penalise him. It is an exclsuive club for the top guys. If  Owners are not present at races , trainers operate at Will.  When Steward cum Owners are not present at the race club , their horses are seen at the rear end of the field. When they make their presence felt horses sprout wings and Win at Will. None to question their illegal and immoral activities. When a jockey pulls a horse on the orders of Bookies or other beneficiaries he is fined / suspended / action taken instantly. When trainer or Owners  themselves  make sure Horse does not perform to its optimum , no action is initiated.
When owners like Poonawala who are / have been at the helm of affairs at RWITC  , let all these activities happen , it makes us wonder as to what their priorities are. Is it for the sake of selling their stud far produce or is this for the sake of getting elected.

Does the horse have to Win only they make appearance in Bangalore / Pune / Mumbai. Rest of the occasions is it okay if trainer loots the public. If the horses are Winning only when they make their presence felt , are they colluding with other trainers / owners ?? to enable them to lead the Winner. Many years ago split sample of a horse which had tested positive ( same trainer ) was being sent abroad. Mysteriously courier consignment got misplaced & when severe action was being contemplated  , consignment was traced in record time. Quite often this trainer opts to run Horses which are not Fit / suffering from fever or other health issues concerning animals . The information is not available to general public prior to the race and is revealed by subsequent race day reports. The odds on most of these horses drift very alarmingly by race time. Surely there is a pattern here. The losers are general public who look at form and past performance before making the investments. No need to guess who the Winners.
Sadly none of these matters will be published in any newspaper or web sites as they themselves are dependent on Stud Farms and Owners  for their financial needs, The  Owners have aptly named it as Mint as  some one is Minting Money  in the process.

Nero, fiddled while the city of Rome was burning , owners are spending crores abroad  purchasing for stud farms.



1 comment:

  1. So interesting. So informative. Really classy article. Paid tipsters learn from edcuated bloggers. You guys only interested in making money and playing with innocent peoples money.

    ReplyDelete


Comments are welcome . They are not moderated to allow free speech. If comments are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous , they could be deleted at later stage . Kindly avoid disclosing personal information of individuals . Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of the blog.

Blogging is a form of sharing information & views . I am glad if blog has proved to be of some Value to all visitors. I prefer to reply on matters relating to racing , when addressed by a person with a Name .