February 3, 2014

The Absurdity of Ratings





A look at the ratings allotted by official handicapper reflects how the warped & outdated system is in force. Take the case of the over hyped horse Murioi which is currently rated at 120 ( highest rating at premier centre )

Can some one explain what this horse has achieved to get this rating . After all it had just about managed a Win in PBM which had enabled a start up rating of 70. Subsequent runs in bangalore were pretty dismal , thereby Bangalore handicapper did not think highly of this Colt. Once it shifted to Mumbai during this season & beat Circle of Life , Rating was increased to 93.  This seems quite normal as horse was conceding weight & comprehensively beat the field. In the very next outing which was the  2000 guineas , it beat the likes of Alaindair ( rated 103 , had Won 2 classics in Blr )  and Mariinsky ( rated 102 , again a Winner of 2 classic earlier  ) . The RWITC handicapper has used his discretion to raise the rating to 120 after this race. A rating above 103 is but natural as horses it had beaten was rated above 100.But how did he ever come to the conclusion that Horse is merited to be rated 120 . That rating is is surely disputable as this Horse had Won only  PBM & 1 Classic ie 2000 Guineas . This sort of upward rating change is unheard off in Indian racing history.Did he raise it going by the hype on the pedigree , isn't he supposed to have his feet on the ground and let the horse do the talking. Why rate it to unreasonable level of 120.

A look at comparitive charts in recent memory shows that  –

The Wonder filly In the Spotlight , which had Won 1000 Guineas at Mysore , Hyderabad Derby , Kolkata 1000 Guineas , Oaks , Derby & Indian Derby was rated at 120 even after so many classic Wins. Subsequent victory in Bangalore  St Leger , President Gold Cup Hyd & Indian St Leger enabled it to reach  130. So despite Winning 6 Classics the handicapper decided it was not good enough to be rated above 120 , Where as Murioi after just 1 Classic Win over a Mile is treated as greatest filly to have graced Indian tracks and rated 120.

Jacqueline which many feel was the best filly to race in india annexed 1000 G , 2000 G , Oaks & Indian Derby all in a single racing season at Mumabi and the same RWITC handicapper deemed it fit to be rated  at 115.

Now that the Indian Derby is through lets look at revised ratings

1.Alaindair 109 to 115
2.Starry Eyes 83 to 101
3.Circle of Life 88 to 100
4.Murioi Retained at 120

Despite beating the highest rated horse in the derby at level weights , Alaindair is rated 5 points below Murioi. The increase in rating in respect of other 2 horses seems realistic , yet to have a beaten horse rated above losing horses displays a basic flaw in racing logic.

The funny part is yet to be seen – Amazing Grace finished 5 th in the Indian Derby and retains a rating of 47 , and the horses it beat Jeremiah ( 112 ) Southern Emperor ( 105 ) Agostini ( 100 ) Isn’t She Special ( 96 ) Keukenhof ( 81 ) Ace Bucephalus ( 75 ) Went Worth ( 67 )  all have higher rating despite losing to a horse rated 47. Horses do have their ON & OFF days and hence it is not practical to change rating after 1 bad run. That much is accepted , with regard to classics ratings of First 4 horses are usually revised. But if Handicapper uses his discretion to make wild changes in rating just as in the same of Murioi why not do it for the rest of the horses.

Now we have a scenario where Amazing Grace raced in 2 classic and clocked a time of 2.29.36 is rated 47 . This was a fast paced race . Class 4 horse Reynolds which also ran derby day in a fast run race and Won clocking 2.31.79 is given a revised rating of 67 ( 46 ) whopping penalty of  21 points. The horse is now eligible to race in class 2 , where as the horse it beat by 10 lenghts Romantic Beauty will still be seen at a low rating of 29.The manner in which it Won , seems to have weighed in the mind of the handicapper. A horse which is a clear 2.30  seconds thereby  superior by 12 lenghts is still rated 47.
Hence the next 2 handicap events in which Amazing Grace competes will be Gift races  practically as  competitors it will be facing which are 1 or 2 classes inferior . On expected lines the Odds may be less than ½ money.

Hidden Asset which won a class V race is rated 39 ( 25 ) and Wild Waves which clocked Won a class V race similarly , 1 second faster time is rated 40 ( 23 )  It is known that race timings are not the sole criteria to judge the merit as the pace of the race matters. In above case , Hidden Asset was gifted the race ( rest of the contenders looked other way ) in DIV 2 , the pace was quite good as Winner Won start to finish. The DIV 1 of the race was fast paced and despite Winning impressively , rating of Wild Waves is just 1 point above Hidden Asset. 

Supreme Star after Winning a class 1 race ( 53. kgs ) in 1.36.36 secs is rated 120 (114 ) & Sheer Class Winning a mile race in class 3 ( 54.50 ) in 1.36.32 secs is rated 66.( 51 )  Different races  can’t be comparable for obvious reasons , nor can the timings clocked but surely the revision in ratings has to have some logic . Surely Sheer Class should have got a higher penalty than 15 points , going by the manner it won the race.

The case of Star Marquess , Chase the Sun , Beauty is Truth , Isn’t She Special , Sur a Tete is all too familiar. None of these horses were / will ever be able to perform to potential ( unless field is consisting of aged / repair horses )  as they have been penalized highly for Winning or doing well in  1 classic race . Their ratings have to come down by another 30 points now to enable a Win. Until then trainers will be content giving runs , punters may back them based on Ratings but their performance will be very poor as ratings alloted are not Genuine.

The handicapper does have some basic guidelines to follow but it should not lead to a situation where a few horses are penalised heavily & some let off  lightly. The circumstances in which the race was run and relative merit of horses has to be viewed. Revision of ratings which was available within 1 hour after completion of races reflects poor judgement on the part of handicapper and concerned club.

It does seem that other clubs  too  , the handicapper works in tandem with a few dubious trainers which enable them to Win races as and When they WISH too , courtesy the Rating Barometer.
 

29 comments:

  1. Respected Shyam Bhai,

    The write up is super and an eye opener. We cannot fight with official handicapper but can use his mistake in our favour.

    As there is a 5 days holiday please give some more eye opener write up.

    Please give a write up on "True Value Odds" How to calculate this and its implementation on real betting.

    You are regularly telling us to avoid heavy betting on ODDS ON FAV. This kind of betting is always risky because normally people take the WIN granted and invest higher amount compare to investment on a fav 2 to 1

    I have just repeated your lines for the benefit of fellow puntures.

    With Regards

    SPS





    Respected Shyam Bhai

    A super Eye Opener Write up.

    In this 5 days gap we can utilise to increase our knowledge.

    Please give a write up on " True Value Odds " How to calculate this and use in our betting.

    Your regular advice of avoiding heavy betting on ODDS ON FAV perhaps will be a part of this

    With Regards.
    SPS








    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes Mr Horsesandraces,

    I am also keen to know what is value bets.

    Let me put it this way. "If the horse has 50% winning chance the odds should be even! So, it is the value bet, if that horse is offered at 2/1. Go and back it. On the other hand, if it is quoted at 60ps then ignore it. That is not the value bet. Similarly if the horse is having 30% winning choice go and bet if the odds are around 3/1 . That is value bet. On the other hand, if it opens at 1.75, then do not bet. Because that is not value bet".

    In that previous paragraph there is no ambiguity. Crystal Clear! But 'crystal clear' to whom? for those who have not seen the race course! To me, I do not know, which calculator gives me whether it is 50% winning horse or 30% winning horse?

    ReplyDelete
  3. all lost what is the point in derby post analysis...

    do u introspect like this every day every day ?

    you make all the poor punters to drain their purse to full bookies walet.

    ...in race course we get khabar(news/tips).

    ...if the horse wins,, the person who gives tips will be in front of you otherwise he will be nowhere....

    he will appear after things cool down.after two or three races..

    ..if u ask him why the horse lost... he will say "ghode ka taang toot gaya...or ghoda gate me
    reh gaya..some stupid standard answers for the failure...after the race is over....

    hope everyone understands...

    ReplyDelete



  4. all lost what is the point in derby post analysis...

    do u introspect like this every day every day ?

    you make all the poor punters to drain their purse to full bookies walet.

    ...in race course we get khabar(news/tips).

    ...if the horse wins,, the person who gives tips will be in front of you otherwise he will be nowhere....

    he will appear after things cool down.after two or three races..

    ..if u ask him why the horse lost... he will say "ghode ka taang toot gaya...or ghoda gate me
    reh gaya..some stupid standard answers for the failure...after the race is over....

    hope everyone understands...

    ReplyDelete
  5. after reading this write up one comes to the conclusion because of the handicapper allotted wrong rating you are not able to pinpoint the winner and made so many punters unhappy...

    If the handicapper had allotted murioi correct rating I think you would have said ALIANDER IS THE WINNER... what a cover up....

    ReplyDelete
  6. Can Manimaran or Vinay Shekaria in their dreams also write an article like this. Never. Compliments Shyam. Great work. Shows how much knowlegde you have and how much you keep a tab on racing in India.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dear Shyam
    Nice to see this wonderful message an eyeopener to all Racing Patrons including clubs handicapper for the future.

    Those who read this article inside of your posting line will surely understand the meaning of the subject.

    Dear Anonymous, [11:10:00 PM GMT+5:30]

    [To my understanding]
    Don't worry about odds of media tips.

    Have a look how the favourite horses open in place in tote display. It will give a value how that betting range horse will perform and where it stand.

    [If the place odds is in ERRATIC lie opening in 11 or 22 and above that clearly show there is some funny] Normally if the betting range horses are open with base on minimum ticket in positive trend like 5 6 7 or 10 11 12 it clearly shows that horse is in on job or do well.]

    Avoid the Betting Range Horses of that race which is "Run of the Race" or having "SET BACK" of Previous Running Method like "Blood Vessel" "Lame" "Hang in and out" etc also unreliable jockey astride and sudden change of equipment which has NOT FITTED for that horses base on Previous Runs and Track work NOT good intention.


    With Warm Regards

    ReplyDelete
  8. To add

    Low odds horses always a RISK Even the returns will be very less after the tax."

    ReplyDelete
  9. Dear Speed Rating
    I could not understand the meaning of following lines of your posting, Please explain in simple language and in some other way:-
    [If the place odds is in ERRATIC lie opening in 11 or 22 and above that clearly show there is some funny] Normally if the betting range horses are open with base on minimum ticket in positive trend like 5 6 7 or 10 11 12 it clearly shows that horse is in on job or do well.]

    Avoid the Betting Range Horses of that race which is "Run of the Race"

    Regards

    SPS

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Wonderful posting Shyam. It is very difficult to remember those points highlighted by you when such horses run in future after a few months from now. Absurd rating indeed.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Quiz: Which is the highest rated horse in India:

    Alandair

    Dandified

    Kohinoor Wish


    None of The above

    ReplyDelete
  13. Dear SPS

    Well, I will explain with example which was observe base on Hyd TOTE Display.....

    [Mumbai Race 2nd Febuary 2014]


    Hidden Asset [Place open 5 and it won with eased]

    STRATEGIC MOVE [Which is hot favourite place open around 11 where as SPEED KING open place in positive trend around 7 [SM Finished finished 6th and SK WON which paid around 60/-


    Way Out [Which is also Hot favourite place open 5 and has WON]

    Supreme Star [Place open around 6 and this also WON]

    Sheer Class and Elite Mode where in Betting Range and SC has open Place 6 and EM open around 11 and former WON and later finished 3rd

    This kind of observation may help us at race time to reduce or increase our selected horses and in second race speed king i have increase the investment for win.

    Even if connections have already have double for the day definitely [except rare case] the other horses will RUN an easy race.


    Run of the Race means open race where upset will be in store.

    Best Wishes.

    ReplyDelete
  14. post mortem is ok but what is the use of such a detailed report about.what went wrong....when the patients are dead

    ReplyDelete

  15. dear sir , please go through the debate in horse talk.

    http://horsetalk.indiarace.com/HTalkPostReply.aspx?msgid=1021466

    is this system of betting possible in india.

    on going through internet , i found this

    http://paceadvantage.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78986&page=2&pp=15

    how do you rate the progressive betting or dutching technique. is this variation fit for indian betting system

    ReplyDelete
  16. I am a premium punter on your roll,what difference you made me today? and one good shot that went off the board, sorry your handicapper is no better than your tips author is my view.
    Prakash Reddy , Hyderabad
    users-imageryI Just followed your red shading horse combined with my own judgement of to back this horse or not, wonderful analysis and i got rewarded on Royal salute and Scenic blast , thanks a lot for publishing how to read your tips and analysis, well I am subscribing now
    Ramesh , Mandya, karnataka
    users-iconsWe have been longing for such a site which is truly punter friendly, simply great,I missed your site because I was diverted by bogus blogs writing bad about you , Amazing for a race punter, I feel if a race punter does not visit you he is missing a lot and why dot you make it free?
    Prakash Ongole

    ReplyDelete
  17. Sad. Feel like crying reading such comments. Foolish guys joins sites for tips.

    ReplyDelete
  18. WE ALL ADMIRE YOUR KNOWLEDGE EXPERTISE, EXPERIENCE, GREAT ENGLISH...YOU THE KING IN RACING ..................................................................................................................................BUT YOU ARE NOT ABLE TO PINPOINT EVEN A SINGLE HORSE IN A DAY...IN A WEEK...IN A MONTH....WHICH WE CAN CONFIDENTLY BET....WHAT IS THE USE ...?

    ReplyDelete
  19. WE ALL ADMIRE YOUR KNOWLEDGE EXPERTISE, EXPERIENCE, GREAT ENGLISH...YOU THE KING IN RACING ..................................................................................................................................BUT YOU ARE NOT ABLE TO PINPOINT EVEN A SINGLE HORSE IN A DAY...IN A WEEK...IN A MONTH....WHICH WE CAN CONFIDENTLY BET....WHAT IS THE USE ...?

    ReplyDelete
  20. UR RESPONSE WILL BE I AM JUST BLOGGING ...!!!!!!


    TO DRAIN THE PUNTERS ?

    ReplyDelete
  21. Registry Registrant ID: BR_18694064
    Registrant Name: Manimaran
    Registrant Organization: -
    Registrant Street: No 47, Vittalrao Nagar, Madhapur, Hitech City
    Registrant City: Hyderabad
    Registrant State/Province: Andhra Pradesh
    Registrant Postal Code: 500081
    Registrant Country: IN
    Registrant Phone: +91.7207297035

    address: CtrlS Datacenters Ltd.
    address: 7th Floor, Pioneer Towers,
    address: Plot No.16, APIIC Software Units Layout,
    address: Madhapur,
    address: Hyderabad - 500081
    country: IN
    phone: +91-40-42030700
    fax-no: +91-40-23116055


    ROGUE MANIMARAN MIND UR BUSINESS
    YOU AE PAID BEGGER
    DONT COMMENT ON FREE BLOGGERS
    NO OBLIGATION TO FOLLOW THEM
    IN UR CASE YOU COLLECT MOENY , YOURE RESPONSIBLE IF TIPS FAIL

    ReplyDelete
  22. Payment Mode: Our site is waiting for the bank approval in other payment GATEWAYintegrations
    SO NOW Please make payment at any icici bank
    to our website admin's S B account
    A/c no 007601531023
    Account with: Jubilee hills Hyderabad
    (Admin)Account holders name : Rangaswamy Manimaran
    You can do internet banking and transfer the amount or simply reach any ICICI bank with the cash and deposit using the above account particulars
    Please tell us which plan you selected after you remit the money and tell us the branch name and code in your mail
    Your account will be activated within 24 hours after receiving your payment.In case you want immediate activation talk to our site admin
    --
    Thanks & Regards,
    Admin - Premium Tips,
    www.indiaracetips.com
    Ph No: +91 905 278 1272.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Does Indiaracetips give receipt for payment collected. Deposit in our current account anywhere in India. If I want receipt will they give. 1.5 lakh scheme they offer.

    ReplyDelete
  24. What is name of current account indiaracetips or manimaran

    ReplyDelete

  25. Owner Manimaran. What else proof required. They take money in Site Admin name savings account.



    Website: indiaracetips.com
    Title: Indian Horse Racing Tips and Analysis
    Type: Sports

    Domain Age: 2 Years, 94 Days
    Website Speed: Slow

    Owner: Manimaran
    Owner Address: No 47, Vittalrao Nagar, Madhapur, Hitech City
    Owner City: Hyderabad
    Owner Postcode: 500081
    Phone Number: 917207297035
    Phone Type: mobile :Andhra Pradesh TATA Indicom / DOCOMO (Virgin Mobile)
    Email:

    Owner Country: India
    Website Location: United States

    ReplyDelete

  26. 190 visitors a day. Shyam blog 3000 a day.


    Indiaracetips.com is currently hosted at Bluehost. This domain is connected to IP address 66.147.242.169 which is hosted on a server that appears to be located in Provo, United States. This domain is ranked number 2680055 in the world. We estimate this website generates about $1 USD of daily revenue. It seems Indiaracetips.com has about 190 daily visitors. Taking into account all these variables, we estimate the value of this website at: $405 USD.
    Hot Bluehost Hosting Deals!

    ReplyDelete
  27. Dear Racing Patrons,

    For Race Guru services, we charge a nominal fee per month (see fee structure). Why do we do this?. Well, think of it this way. Why do you have to ‘bet’ some money on a horse before getting the ‘dividends’?!. So, one perspective is, before earning dividends for yourself because of Race Guru, you are paying a fee! , the way, race course / clubs deduct a percentage of pooled money before the dividends are paid out.

    In fact, its waste of time & energy to do this service free of cost. We can understand if it is JUST DAILY TIPS but our services are much more than JUST DAILY TIPS..

    Also, following are the key reasons why we charge a fee to our members

    We at Race Guru have employed few skilled people for various types of data analytic work. We have to pay them salary every month
    We host our website on a shared server. We have to pay fees for this every month.
    Racing is a game which keeps evolving over a period of time. We have to keep ourselves updated with new methods, knowledge, approaches etc.. for which we invest. It can be books, paid consultation with our mentors (Race Guru’s Gurus!) in India, US, UK, Australia & other countries where horse racing is more advanced.
    Over a period of many years, we have developed our own software, systems etc.. we are giving the best output of this on a platter to you. Also, for providing tips, detailed race card analysis takes lot of time & energy. You have seen how often we give successful fluke tips. We also have reliable connections wherever required. We may have to pay commissions to these connections at regular intervals (Remember: A horse may look best on paper but only few key people know whether its ON JOB or NOT on the racing day). This also deserves a fee (as nothing comes free)
    ‘Racing Secrets’ section is a repository of best practices in racing / betting from around the world. Again, you are getting access to this knowledge base instantly .When we give tips, we are actually feeding you with fish but in this section, we are teaching you ‘how to fish’? Therefore, there is a huge potential for you to make a fortune in racing if you read & understand these concepts passionately which calls for a fee.
    Also, when we have taken fees from you, we become committed and guide you carefully because you will become our CUSTOMERS. We believe in customer satisfaction.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Der Shyam

    "WE ALL ADMIRE YOUR KNOWLEDGE EXPERTISE, EXPERIENCE, GREAT ENGLISH...YOU ARE THE KING IN RACING.......BUT YOU ARE NOT ABLE TO PINPOINT EVEN A SINGLE HORSE IN A DAY...IN A WEEK...IN A MONTH....WHICH WE CAN CONFIDENTLY BET....WHAT IS THE USE ...?"

    With reference to above Please Introduce at least one CONFIDENT TIP as day best and if possible One (or) Two additional tips as Good Double. This may not be possible every day but when ever possible do not forget.

    After all common puntures cannot understand & utilise your in depth knowladge of racing. They expect few good confident bets for punting.

    With Regards

    SPS


    ReplyDelete
  29. IF readers in this blog or other blog want to be spoon fed join paid tipsters. You will get racing secrets and also they blessings for donating to them.

    ReplyDelete


Comments are welcome . They are not moderated to allow free speech. If comments are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous , they could be deleted at later stage . Kindly avoid disclosing personal information of individuals . Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of the blog.

Blogging is a form of sharing information & views . I am glad if blog has proved to be of some Value to all visitors. I prefer to reply on matters relating to racing , when addressed by a person with a Name .