Thoughts,opinions and musings of a restless Blogger. What I see from where I am & how I see it. You could say , original & insightful , therefore this blog exists. It gives me deep fulfillment if it could give happiness to the reader
May 22, 2017
GST - Impact on Horse Racing
Hi all..
The much awaited GST rates have been published by the Council after intensive discussions with the stake holders ...
The basic intent of GST is to have a uniform tax rate for the same product across the country. At present each state has framed VAT rates for various items sold within the territory. A few states offered concessions for a few products manufactured to attract investment or for employment generation. This resulted in pricing difference for same product in different states even if the manufacturer had multiple locations . As far as Services are concerned it was a Single rate fixed by the Centre through the Finance act passed in budget ..
With Introduction of GST ..both Goods and services come under single framework. Obvious a few sections of the industry would be benefited while a few others may feel that taxes are raised unjustly.
Coming to races.. The initial responses from all stakeholders is Tax @ 28% is on Turnover which is unfair to all concerned..
I am responsible for what I say or write but not for what you understand. So read it and interpret any which way.. As a punter this is what i understand :
Bookies and Club management are mainly responsible for this hike in Taxes. All these years Bookies gobbled up Tax amount by tempting punters to bet at Half Tax . When club issues license to operate Stall inside premises.. It is their duty to ensure all bets are recorded.. Punters are settled of their dues and taxes remitted to Govt. But club allowed illegal half tax collections thereby denying state of its Legitimate dues. Each book maker accepts bets for 2-3 lacs per race at the minimum.. Going up to 10-12 lacs depending on type of race.. Number of runners etc.. Even assuming 20 lacs collection per day.. 2 lacs is half tax generated by each bookie without any effort. This goes towards balancing their books - exposure on bets accepted or leads to bumper illegal unaccounted income which was in cash.. Not accounted for.. No taxes paid.. A rough estimate would put bookie earnings at 150 crores per year by way of half tax cheating.. Work out figures for past 20 years.. U know the illegal money..tax loss to govt.. So why would Govt agree now to lower taxes if they are denied rightful taxes.. Sum remitted to govt is not even 2% of actual tax collected.. Unless club management gives approval.. Bookies wont have courage to do illegal activities in club.. For all you know.. Bookies may gave shared the tax booty with corrupt club management..
Vivek Jain. Ramakrishnan. Surendranath Reddy. Jaganath and past chairmen + commitee members of all clubs are totally to blame for this half tax menance and should be put behind bars for facilitating illegal betting on club premises.. Denying Govt of its share of Income.. When these swines can install CCTV and appoint bouncers to check use of Mobiles. What prevents them from installing Cctv in bookies ring and ensure tax complaince..
And punters expect these pigs to fight for lower GST now ? Lets not forget even their expenses on travel to meet finance ministry officials was funded by Punters. End result is still the same... And now shamelessly these pimps have called for chairmen meeting to decide on future. Are you guys above the law to conduct races and not collect GST. If it is law.. None can avoid collecting and remitting it.. Punters will pay for it.. why travel first class by Plane.. Stay eat and shit in Five Star Hotel at our expense.. If you have any shame or morality resign immediately.. Punters are mainstay of racing.. And you rogues have let them down by facilitating bookies to earn large sums of money.. Denying govt of its dues.. Reason for taxes to be hiked..
Each club conducts racing by offering stake money to horse Owners. The club generates a major portion of its revenue by way of deductions from the Totalliser Pool which is a sum total of contributions from punters.. In addition a small portion does come in from Sponsorship of big races ...
Gate entry fees..phone charges.. Fees for using premises for canteen / sale of other edible products.
Betting tax is deducted and remitted to Govt from Tote collections.. Club does not bear any part of betting tax. All its expenses have to be borne from its CUT in tote. Basic money management involved. Goes without saying that Privileged club members get lot of facilities at subsidized rates. No loss to club as such. Only loser is Punter community which invests Rs 100 but gets back only 87 by way of Dividends ( at Blr) or 70 in Mumbai under current betting rules ... Betting with bookies can lead to loss of Punter or Bookie depending on the outcome. The bookie pays a stall fee to the Club + is also required to collect & remit tax to Govt. But rarely pays Govt of taxes collected..
So indirectly Punter meets Club Expenses including Salaries to Thousands of staff employed by club..Punters fund Stake Money paid to Owner's for Winning races , Owner's pay Jockey's riding fee & Trainers Basic Training Fee from their own resources and or from Stake money earned in races.. Owner's buy horses to race from Breeders.. If racing is not conducted... Owner will not buy horses or pay Trainer fees ...in absence of return on investment. Breeders are not charitable to just let horses breed & pay for their upkeep. They breed to Sell & earn in the process.. Even race book publishers and vendors are dependent on punters..
In India punter is least organized.. Gets a raw deal.. Despite paying for all racing activities.. In the end he is also the ultimate loser... The privileged Club.. Owners. Breeders. Trainers. Jockeys all EARN and make substantial profits..
GST at 28% is a loss to punters as their own funds go to Govt coffers , In addition to funding rest of the industry.. No two ways about it. Those who used to get 20 for a Tenner may get only 16-17 ... If dividend was 17 earlier.. may get only 15 after GST. This will lead to reduction in tote collections as payouts become unattractive.. which further reduces - club income.. Thereby Stakes to owners.. Btf to trainers..etc etc.,
As Punter is largely losing in this process.. Is it not time to rejoice at 28% tax.. Which will ruin the industry bringing it to standstill ...but at least punters losses will be reduced in absence of punting... and future generations can survive happily without a debt burden.. It's not as if Punters are millionaires presently & they will miss racing.. The clubs.. Breeders... Trainers..bookies will find it tough to survive without races..
For 25 years Madras Race club was looted by MAM ..racing was a farce.. Without any punters contribution they managed to swindle crores by selling property and giving high stake money to class vb horses.. 95% of stake was earned by MAM.. Current chairmen kept quiet all these years.. Now talks of high taxes..
Hrc swindled govt of taxes on shp bets received for many years.. Chairman now talks of unfair GST..
Rwitc tried to con govt of its revenues and even land ownership by trying to sublease land to a developer. Facilitated bookies by killing Tote.. Never represented successfully to Local state Govt to reduce taxes from 20% ..how the hell can these jokers convince Central Govt to reduce..
In the end BTC HRC and Mysore Race Clubs which were punter friendly have to bear the brunt of higher GST.. Its not as if Arun Jaitley approved rates personally on 1200 + items.. It was state finance ministers who get to decide.. If Rwitc was paying 20% and rate is reduced to 12 or 18 ..maharastra govt will object.. So indirectly rwitc shit practises have killed indian racing..
Btc turnover is 2000 crores.. Taxes paid 160+ crores to state govt.. If gst is on club commission say 5% as some claim.. Its like 28 crores.. Why should karnataka forego 132+ crores... Seriously.
Horse race betting is restricted to Southern states of Karnataka. Tamil Nadu. Andra Pradesh. Telengana and from rest of India only Maharashtra & Delhi. So its not that all indians are affected by this move. Punter population is not more than 1 lac.. Its time to save these 1 lac ppl than try to make them fund rogue breeders owners and clubs for rest of their lives.. So lets rejoice for this GST 28% ..no need for reduction of taxes. Let racing die..
Just in case racing still continues with Higher GST.. No issues.. Punters are ready to forego 35% towards GST and Club commission.. But make sure no Legal bookie operates from within club premises by doing half tax business..if they are seen.. Please report to Prime Minister Office .. GST cell.. Finance department of State / Centre.. Police.. To ensure they don't get away scot free.. File complaint against club for facilitating cheating by bookies.. No official however powerful will have guts to support bookies cheating govt of gst..
3 comments:
Comments are welcome . They are not moderated to allow free speech. If comments are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous , they could be deleted at later stage . Kindly avoid disclosing personal information of individuals . Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of the blog.
Blogging is a form of sharing information & views . I am glad if blog has proved to be of some Value to all visitors. I prefer to reply on matters relating to racing , when addressed by a person with a Name .
EXCELLENT AND MARVELLOUS POSTING K S P SIR... THE GREAT... Thank you... DADAJI FROM KAZHIABAD...
ReplyDeleteOnly in India bookies are allowed to operate. If I'm wrong please let me know which country bookies operate inside race courses. In other countries race club surivive even after online betting is available for punters. BTC chsowed the way by removing bookies. BTC is surviving. Read Ikram Khan review on Bangalore races were he says outside bookies still operate at Bangalore. Outside bookies will function whether they are banned or not. It is upto the clubs to make it profitable. What use of having night racing when the outcome is the same.
ReplyDeleteShyam Bhai your article is any eye opener for the sleeping club officials.
ReplyDeleteEven now their are illegal Bookies operating inside Bangalore race course for all the races Can any official stop this.
It looks like the next generation punters will be Happy by just watching racing has sports on TV And but saving an fourtune.