October 30, 2008

Pune racing season 2008

One more racing season concluded and as usual most punters and patrons get the feeling that merit took a back seat on most racing days and questionable rides were the order of the day. But if looked in a practical and logical way , then I suppose Punters should be happy as the consistency shown for the past many years continues again .At the end of the day the most of the paying punters take a decision based on the circumstances prevailing at race time .Hence if there were NEGATIVE signals at race time , it was prudent to avoid backing the fancied horses .I think there is no point complaining post event. Only those who bet based on opening odds prior to races can feel cheated by the subsequent race results , and that TOO only in case there is the element of doubt on the genuineness of the race.

There were several close finishes which enthralled all of us as well as many lop sided races. There were many Decisions taken after the races which raised eye brows as these were shorn of merit.

Be that as it may , what matters finally is the official Tally at the end of the season of some of the trainers are as follows :


Trainer Name Wins Fav Loss Fav Wins

Narendra Lagad 22 14 7
P. Shroff 19 14 13
Imtiaz Sait 17 11 5
M.P.Jodha 15 4 5
K.Ganapathy 13 7 9
Mansoor Shah 12 6 8
Faisal A.Abbas 11 4 3
D.Todywalla 10 6 2
C.D.Katrak 10 7 7
Vinayak 10 3 7


Top Jockeys -

Jockey Name Wins Fav Loss Fav Wins
1 M.Narredu 26 19 12
2 K.P.G.Appu 20 11 13
3 C.Rajendra 15 18 12
4 Wayne Smith 13 9 5
5 Samuel Fargeat 12 5 8
6 Y.S.Srinath 12 6 10
7 Sunny Chinoy 11 5 3
8 Nirmal Jodha 10 11 2
9 C.S.Jodha 9 2 2
10 P.Kamlesh 9 4 7


The best based on the consistency and return on investment would be :

1.Jockeys : K.P.G,Appu , Mallesh Narredu and C.S.Jodha

2.Trainers : Pesi Shroff ,H J Antia , M P Jodha and M Shah..



As far as the worst are concerned the nominees are :

1.Jockeys : R.Shelar ,Riyaz Shiakh and both the Imported guys.

2.Trainers : S.K.Sunderji and Dallas Todywala.


Undoubtedly Mallesh Narredu has been a revelation during this season and Punters got to see him in positive light in respect of most races barring a few questionable rides which though condemnable , should be seen in the context of the success ratio
I particularly liked his rides astride : Ikaria , Congrats , Vantage and a few of MP Jodha’s Horses. Among the worst rides were Saltoro and Aurora Aurelias .

C S Jodha might seem to be a surprise inclusion for many , but if his statistics is analysed , it is very clear that HE HAD THE best return on investment .The very fact that the Horses won at longer odds itself indicates that the Jockey was honest in his efforts.It is very very rare to see a Horse ridden by Top Jockeys winning at Longer odds .The reason is simple , if the Horse is expected to WIN ,the news get across very fast to all those concerned. When the Horse is quoted at LONGER ODDS in respect of the leading jockeys , it is very evident the intent to WIN is lacking. When seen in that context C S Jodha comes out FIRST as most of the races WON by him were long shots .It is also pertinent to note that losses on fancied Horse were minimal in his case.

K P G Appu did perform credibly for the Two retained owners and usually picked up Winners at Good odds .He did blot his record by his actions on a few of F A Abbas trained horses . He was unlucky not to have a mount in the derby and there are a few who felt that Dancing Dynamite might have done well if he was entrusted with the task. However , he did get lucky on a few occasions like when Rejuvinite won the race against Oasis Star and also when his Objection was upheld against Autonomy. Both his rides on Exuberance were outstanding as the Horse came from way off the pace to Strike at Lucrative odds. I am mentioning this as Appu is generally regarded as a Start to Finish specialist.

Other so called Top Jockeys like Rajendra , W Smith , S Fargeut did not do justice on many occasions and punters felt cheated by the lack of sincere effort in the saddle , particularly when the Horses were in the Odds. The ones to benefit by all these actions were the Book makers who made merry.

Srinath and Sunny Chinoy did well for the respective stables as and when the MONEY was on the horse. When the odds were not in favor they were too happy to oblige those who benefited. Judging the performance by the Number of Victories or the percentage would not do justice as many a time the Horse itself is not equipped to Win or due to other quality contenders in the field. However the failed favorites though can be a measure of judging the performance , though the Odds for the Horse has no relation to the relative merit of the Horse.

Kamlesh , T S Jodha , Nirmal Jodha and Adesh Kumar did well when expected .As and when there was no Intent they ensured that the Horse ran below par.They did well for the main stables riding vigoursly but in respect of other mounts were mere passengers.

One Jockey who deserves Special mention is OZA for the spectacular Win on Secret Glory .One is not sure if it was his Birthday as the WIN came after many years of doing duty .The Horse has not subsequently participated , which leaves us to ponder on , whether the Horse was Just too good or it Won due to the Jockey Merit at .45 paisa ODDS.


Coming to the Trainers , Most punters have very extreme and fanatical views on Narendra lagad for his success as the Champion Trainer. While the title is not debatable , the means adopted can definitely be discussed .He started off the season in style and kept picking winners at Will during the first half of the season. Subsequently it was a drab affair as most of his fancied horses failed repeatedly. His decision to enter the Horses in most races left punters in no doubt what so ever , and it was obvious that he was obliging fellow trainers in order to ensure that the races were not declared Void. Coming from the same family , it makes sense to help each other by giving entries and then ensuring that the Horses with Higher odds WIN.The last few meetings were practically a Joke as in several events he had multiple entries and NONE of the Horses were really on contention. Tactics make races and if one goes through the races and his Horses , one would invariably find that the same instructions were never given / followed. Followers of form / handicapping were at a loss and could never relate to His Wins or could accept the Loss against some mediocre rivals.


M P Jodha was definitely going through a bad patch since 2006 and this season was definitely remarkable and lucrative , as most of his Horses have some ordinary bloodlines and did well against expectations. He was also a party to the Numbers game and in most races , none of his Horses were in contention for even place but were running to accommodate the other friendly stables. Mallesh Narredu rode a few well judged races for this low key Trainer.

M Shah , definitely had a very good season with many winners for his Owner Haresh Mehta along with a few for the Hyderabad based V N babu. Was unlucky to miss out on the derby but he may not complain for having picked up some good winners like Rejuvinite , Snow Blind and Exuberance. Unfortunately he was also a party to some shocking failures on fancied Horses and most Bookies picked it the signals early on. There were a lot of coincidences when his Horses were in the fray and most often He picked up a double or alternatively all his Runners flopped. It helped that he had some powerful Owners to support his cause. For the first time in many years the trainer was not suspended during the racing season. For the past 10 years invariably , his license would be suspended for not allowing the horses to run on Merit.

Pesi Shroff did well to silence his critics towards the end of the season by picking up many quality races including the Derby. His choice of Jockeys was definitely questionable , as many a favorite lost under suspicious circumstances. The horses which were blazing the tracks / had won a race earlier , ran like duds subsequently and Rajendra had partnered a few.

Antia surprisingly delivered at pune as usually Mumbai is his forte. His winning horses sprouted a pair of wings and WON convincingly merely by changing the equipment .He was the master of execution as most of his Horses WON easily as and when asked.

I A Sait also had a good season , after the disaster at Mumbai. However he was also guilty of failing on some fancied runners and Winning when least expected.Small time trainers like Abbas, Altaf , Dallas Todywala, M K Jadhav , Anil Kumar and a few others made merry winning at lucrative odds and losing when the horses were fancied. Most of these Trainers had a terrible record on fancied Horses and obviously the news of the horses Losing was taken on well by his pet bookies .

Trainers like Ivor Fernandes , Subhag Singh , Nirad Karanjwala , Arti Doctor were pathetic and one really wonders as to how Owners retain confidence in them.Many trainers picked up races at random and rating them in the light of the Wins or losses would not be appropriate.Some like S K Sunderji were really not interested in Pune racing and gave entries to keep the Horses fit..When a trainer retains R Shelar to ride for him , it is blatantly clear that he has no intention to even let the Horse run on merit.

Close finishes in these races were thrilling and many punters waited with bated breadth for the official results in respect of a few races of which the closest were
Rejuvinite / Oasis Star and Flaming Ace / Autonomy.

By the First week of October most punters were dejected and disheartened by the results and lost interest due to the inconsistency shown by most Horses. The last few race meetings also saw the withdrawl of large number of Horses due to Medical reasons , thereby leaving punters with limited options .However even here , some fancied runners did not do well and Punters were fuming at the lackluster performance of a few horses. Suffice to say that the confidence levels in Western India Horse Racing were down to an all time low.

With the Mumbai racing season being delayed and scheduled to start only by the First week of December , Punters have a lot of time to recuperate and think of New strategies to be followed .

We do have the Bangalore races from 7 th of November and Hopefully , we should see some good action.


Comments and feedback welcome

5 comments:

  1. Nicely said but to forgot to mention SS Baria and I shiekh who can really ride a horse out when the RIGHT money is on them.

    Well done

    ReplyDelete
  2. very well written covering all aspects of pune season.If u cud compile a list of horses which can strike early in Mumbai season based on performance in pune,that wud be a big benifit to all.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I feel this can be the most complimentary assessment of the Pune season that can be. Considering the rout that we punters faced.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Vikram ,

    This is the Final Summary.


    below 50 paisa 14

    .51 and Even 27
    1.05 to 2 to 1 47
    2.10 to 4 to 1 60

    4.10 to 6 to 1 41
    Above 6 to 1 44


    If you break up these into THREE groups it is evident that .51 to 4 to 1 had more than 57 % Winners.I am sure punters are happy to back at these ODDS.

    I do agree that we had 85 LONG SHOTS but 37 % is quite OK with international standards.

    6 % were winners at ODDS which no Sane person backs.

    So overall Value for MONEY bets were to the extent of 57 % which is not bad unless you have the view that the BOOK maker is the most intelligent guy in racing and therefore 100 % of Winners should arise from the Favorites AS declared by them.


    SHYAM

    ReplyDelete
  5. IS IT? SEEMS PUNE WAS LUCRATIVE...BEATS THE HELL OUT OF ME...PUNE SEASON CONTINUES TO CONFOUND ME STILL.

    ReplyDelete


Comments are welcome . They are not moderated to allow free speech. If comments are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous , they could be deleted at later stage . Kindly avoid disclosing personal information of individuals . Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of the blog.

Blogging is a form of sharing information & views . I am glad if blog has proved to be of some Value to all visitors. I prefer to reply on matters relating to racing , when addressed by a person with a Name .