Thoughts,opinions and musings of a restless Blogger. What I see from where I am & how I see it. You could say , original & insightful , therefore this blog exists. It gives me deep fulfillment if it could give happiness to the reader
April 6, 2009
Ripley's believe it not .
the ratings at the handicap stage ( as per the RWITC WEB SITE ) for the Indian Derby reflects the absolute lack of common sense of the official handicapper .
This rating is totally off the mark going by the relative performance of the horses in the field.Not sure of what guidelines are followed but surely this CANT be TRUE.
1.Abs Fabs 122 , Accepted , it is a Derby Winner TWICE OVER ( but NOT AT
the main race centres ) .Other classic WINS - NIL . Lost thrice to Ice Breaker Yet rated HIGHEST and we see Ice breaker at the Bottom.So Much importance to the Kolkatta Derby WIN. Wondering what ratings would be given to OOTY and Chennai Derby Winners.Handicapper feels that it is better then Set Alight ?? This horse has Lost more races than it has WON in its career.
2.Set Alight 117 ONLY HORSE with an unbeaten record among the contestants.One Front line Derby Winner in addition to several classics to its credit.Performace till date speaks more than words.
3.Autonomy 115 Winner of last year PBMM , has WON a CLASS 1 race and the 2000 Guineas.
4.Riyasat 114 ( quantum jump from 45 to 114 , ie 69 points after the OAKS WIN ) WOW this must be some record.Could not win a CLASS 3 RACE earlier now rated Higher than Class 1 Horses ?? With this higher rating i cant see this Horse WINNING any handicap races as the PENALTY is STEEP.
5.Dancing Dynamite 113 . Ran close to Autonomy in mumbai 2000 guineas , not so lucky in Pune DERBY , yet placed ahead of ICE BREAKER ?? Not WON any big events till date . Yet rated 113 , How is that ??? Last Win was in October 2008 but ICE Breaker has WON 2 Classics in 2009.
DD beat ICE Breaker as a youngster in the Mumbai 2008 season.
6.Juventus 111 , a pure handicapper.
7.Nora 110 , lost a class IV race to Falcon Crest. CLASSICS Wins : ZERO , yet ahead of ICE Breaker.
8.Fantastic Quest 109 , lost so many races in bangalore , notably to Perpetuity and Splendid Surprise. Was unable to BEAT Ice Breaker , yet is ONE point ahead.
9.Ice Breaker 108 , @ the bottom of the PILE.Won 3 Classics in the recently concluded bangalore Winter season .
Good day,
shyam
1 comment:
Comments are welcome . They are not moderated to allow free speech. If comments are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous , they could be deleted at later stage . Kindly avoid disclosing personal information of individuals . Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of the blog.
Blogging is a form of sharing information & views . I am glad if blog has proved to be of some Value to all visitors. I prefer to reply on matters relating to racing , when addressed by a person with a Name .
hahaha should call it RWITC's believe it or go home
ReplyDelete