April 27, 2009

who can clarify ??

Tactics is something which decides the outcome of the in 90 % of the races.Irrespective of the relative Horse / Jockey merit often it is the tactics deployed which decide the WINNER.

In case the Rider makes a false move / tactical error at a crucial stage of the race , it would be too late to recover lost ground as even a fraction of a Second lost during the race makes a difference to the eventaul outcome .

As noticed on Television and also based on the race day report , the impression, WE get is that the Trainer is the ONE who gives in the instructions to the concerned Jockey.Once in a while the Jockey is asked to ride his OWN RACE thereby the judgement is to his discretion.

The riding instruction are usually based on the Trainers reading of the race and their experience of working with the Horse .Tactics usually change based on the distance and also considering the racing pattern of other Horses in the fray.

The reason for this post is the recent riding skills displayed by apprentice Jockey N.S.Parmar . Mallesh is also considered for his ride in the Casino Royale Million Race.


Jockey N.S.Parmar , who rides for Vinayak and Shroff has been doing well over the past month and what I noticed that Jockey N.S.Parmar , when riding on a fancied Horse , has the tendency of bringing the Horse to the centre of the track right from the start , or take it wide outside when the Horse is asked for an effort.This has been seen on all His WINNING mounts till date , be it Sioux Chief , Thanda , Swahili , Cavaradosi , Chios , Phospher , Encouragement , Tsesebe or Absolute Reality.He also displayed similar skills , on some losing horses like Blue jay , Cyclades , Cotswold Arms etc. All this is Fine and is appreciated as he has shown great courage and talent in Winning against other seasoned professionals.In all these cases the Horse was fancied strongly irrespective of the book maker odds , on account of its previous performance or on account of the advantage in the scales.Iam sure the Money of the Trainer / Owner was on the Horse on all these Horses.

But his recent rides on some horses notably Solor and Catalyst over the weekend defies logic.In the first instance Highland was strongly fancied and Solor was at longer odds.the betting did indicate that the Horse was not fancied by those who matter.

As always fancied Horses from certain owners get the preference as Breeders and Owners need to co exist.The race followed true to betting .Solor in all the three earlier runs was always kept handy in the initial stages and then asked for an effort by taking the Horse Wide at the home bend or at the 200 metre marker.On saturday the Horse was kept to the railings all along and only after the Winner made the Move and surged ahead the jockey tried to catch up with a belated effort .Result ?? did not suceed as the Intent to do so was lacking.

Catalyst , WON very well at longer odds when Ridden by David Allen at top handicap.It was also seen to drift to the outside track at the closing stages of the race it WON.

So the instruction of the trainer must have been similar on both SOLOR and Catalyst.

On Sunday , Catalyst was not fancied to WIN and bookies were generous to offer Place odds also. As expected the Horse was kept to the railings by the Jockey , behind a wall of Horses and when asked for effort at a crucial stage came up very well but could not beat the WINNER WAHY .

The tactics used on both the Horse trained by Nina Lalwani leads us to question the logic. Was the Jockey asked to do so by the trainer ? or was that a independent decision taken by a apprentice Jockey ?? The latter does not seem possible .

Does the RWITC conduct an enquiry only when the Favorite Loses or when only when the Horse involved is one in which they are involved ??

Why is that Trainers / Jockeys are not questioned when an indifferent ride is noticed.


Second case on hand is Arts . On Debut the Horse was a Moral bet for WIN and there were no takers for most of the Horses in the fray.However there was some some last minute betting on River Blossom .In this case David Allen on ARTS was not very keen to take the Horse to the front and it finally cost the Race. Not a surprise that the Winner RIVER BLOSSOM , was owned by Rakesh Kumar Wadhwan who has PLENTY of Horses with C.D.Katrak trained Arts and was ridden by Daniel Grant.

In the next Outing also Arts allowed Whispering Willows to surge ahead but caught up with the runner up , close to the post as the runner up was seen tiring. In the Third appearance on the track , over 1 400 metre race , Arts was again not asked for an effort until it was too late.Considering the fact that it lost to may superior horses and the end result was close , One can accept the result at face value.

Sunday saw three runners facing the starter and 2 of the Horses were from C.D.Katrak with Arts not being fancied from the betting point of view. Aristocratical belong to Mumbai based owners was the fancied horse and had the credentials to WIN. The favorite was Smokin Aces , who had WON impressively on Debut , but beating some Horses which were beaten comprehensively by Arts in an earlier race. Besides Arts and Aristocratical had the benefit of participating with some superior horses like Forest Flair , Versaki , Austral flash etc. in some highly visible prestigious races .

In most of the Three Horse races , all of them have a equal chance of scoring unless the Favorite is a Horse with impressive credentials like Set Alight or Oasis Star and the rest merely there to collect the stake money offered by the CLUB.We have seen many such races taking place and the result of most of them is a forgone conclusion .in this particular race , My reading did indicate that all three had a good chance but in view of past experience , Smoking Aces had no chance what so ever to WIN.

While no one can question the Bookies ODDS and the way the favorites are decided , what was shocking was the decision to make ARKS the pace setter for the race. Having being ridden off the pace in all the 3 starts , by deciding to send it to the front to ACT as a pacemaker to the FANCIED stable mate Aristocractical
, the Horse was denied a chance to WIN the race. Not that it would have WON if it the earlier tactics was used .It may have lost , but that is a different matter.

The Owners being in Delhi may not mind this loss as there are several other races in the past / in the future which was given ( will be given ) on a platter when they decide to make a Visit to the race course .

Punters who bet on HORSES , do so on some assumptions.One of them being that the Horse would be given a fair chance to score and would be ridden in the same manner as earlier unless the race distance varies to a large extent.

In all the above three cases , punters who bet on them Lost out.


Who decides on whether a Enquiry is to be called for ?? The Stewards who are also Owners and big Gamblers decide on these matters , depending on the way the end result pans out.The race report and incidents can be seen on the official web site of the club.

But most of these enquiry cases are those in which these Stake holders are interested or when there is a genuine case of hooking a horse.

What needs to be done is to take action even in those cases , where a change in pattern of running is noticed and action taken irrespective of whether the Horse is a fancied runner or a Long shot as the end loser is always the Punter.


As Solor, Catalyst and Arts was tipped , I may come across as a Loser, complaining post race , but in reality a negative bet on Smokin Aces and a each way bet on Catalyst ensured that the I did not lose out .I am raising these issues as a normal punter who gets frustrated when Horses are not allowed to run on merit.


shyam




5 comments:

  1. Dear Shyam Bhai,

    This Article has given me additional confidance in you, now I know how deep you are involved & your selection is not just on the merit of the horse but you also consider many more facts.

    It is a well known fact that there are many EXTERNAL FORCES which alters the final result. No one can know these forces fully but only using SIXTH SENCE can guess upto some extent and I feel by and large you are quite capable due to your regular effort, good memory,and ability to analyse.

    The Strike Rate Is A Proof of This.

    Never Mind The Critisiser, They Are Good For Nothing.

    With Regards.

    Surendra Prasad Sao

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your observations are very keen and very much true. An enquiry must be opened by the stewards on running of ARTS on Sunday.

    ReplyDelete
  3. So We can Presume that in future you will enlighten us regarding the "OTHER" considerations in your postings ,so that we can give due weightage to all factors before deciding the horse for the race.
    One thing that stuck me after the race was that "the only winner of Pesi Shroff during the week-end races(16)was KARL UMRIGAR trophy(The late Karl Umrigar was brother-in-law,wife's brother,of Pesi.)
    If you come across such information beforehand,i request you to post the same in your blog for the proper analysis.
    Please keep up the good work for the punters like me who spend their hard-earned money on this sport for the love of HORSE RACING.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Interesting Comment Shyam however in the case of Parmar you are right that most of his wins have been when the horse has been ridden from the outside if you think about it then you can understand why, bring the horse from the outside and running him on the center of the track helps jockeys with no whip as they dont have to negiogiate tru traffic. AS they cant force sudden acceration from their horse as they dont have the whip to do so hence its logical to show daylight to a horse from the out side and push him to the post without any interference and in a smooth and and steady way.
    As Far as Arts is concerned I dont think there was any intents for the owners or trainers to run the horse in a start to finish manner at the start Arastrocratical was sluggish and Smoking Aces was choked to stay in second place and Malesh did the right thing by letting Arts just take the lead and not let him fight 4 his head too.
    Regarding trainers instructions I can see your point but its always hersay and difficult to prove unless every trainer instruction is recoded pre race which will never happen for obvious reasons.

    ReplyDelete


Comments are welcome . They are not moderated to allow free speech. If comments are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous , they could be deleted at later stage . Kindly avoid disclosing personal information of individuals . Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of the blog.

Blogging is a form of sharing information & views . I am glad if blog has proved to be of some Value to all visitors. I prefer to reply on matters relating to racing , when addressed by a person with a Name .